INDEPENDENT THINKING. ON EVERY BLOCK.RESEARCH / REVIEWS / GUIDES

What does an exchange’s proof of reserves actually prove?

Read a crypto exchange’s proof-of-reserves report, check what a Merkle proof tells you, and see how the choice of liabilities changes a reserve ratio.

A magnifying glass sits on the counter in front of an open bank vault.

An exchange publishes a graphic showing 105% bitcoin reserves. Before taking that as a promise about your next withdrawal, look for the two numbers behind the percentage. Which bitcoin did someone verify, and which obligations did they count? A ratio can be calculated correctly and still answer a much narrower question than the one you have.

Read the fraction in units of the asset

Suppose a report identifies 105 BTC controlled by a platform at noon and 100 BTC owed to the customer accounts included in the review. Dividing the first figure by the second gives 105% coverage for that group at noon. A reader can reproduce the arithmetic without making any assumption about the dollar price of bitcoin.

Now suppose the same company also owes a lender 12 BTC due that afternoon. In this hypothetical, there are no other assets or debts. Including the additional obligation changes the calculation to 105 ÷ 112, or 93.75%. The first fraction still describes its original group. It just leaves out a creditor whose claim matters to anyone asking whether all withdrawals and debts can be met.

What a personal Merkle proof adds

Some platforms give you a way to verify that your balance was among the records they used. They combine balance records into a branching structure called a Merkle tree and publish a short value called its root. Your proof lets you check that your entry connects to that root. First check the balance in the entry against your own statement for the same timestamp.

In its September 30, 2026 snapshot, Kraken reported a bitcoin reserve ratio of 103.2%. For every 100 BTC of customer balances covered, it reported 103.2 BTC of reserves at that point in time. Customers can also check whether their own balance was included. That check answers a different question from whether the company owes money to other creditors or still holds the same assets today.

Three lines worth finding in the report

As of when? Record the snapshot time separately from the day the announcement was posted. Whose assets and liabilities? Find the legal entity, tokens, products and customer groups named. What did the reviewer do? Read the actual procedures and exceptions. A displayed wallet address on its own supplies little information about obligations or other parties’ rights over those funds.

The PCAOB Office of the Investor Advocate’s advisory explains the limits of these engagements and how they differ from financial statement audits. When comparing centralized exchanges, keep a note of any question the document leaves open. That note may tell you more than the largest number in the headline.